Episode 10: A PRETTY YOUNG BRIDE DISAPPEARS
- 20 hours ago
- 8 min read
SHE KISSED HER HUSBAND GOODBYE AND NEVER CAME HOME
The heartbreaking true story of Suzanne Logan — the pretty young bride who went to the mall and vanished forever
She was 21 years old, nine months married to the man her brothers called her prince, and she had everything to live for.
On a sunny Sunday morning in March 1984, Suzanne Logan — Susie to everyone who loved her — dropped her husband Brian at work, gave him a kiss, and drove to Penn Square Mall in Oklahoma City. She had a Tupperware appointment at 4pm. She was thinking about a career in fashion design. She and Brian were talking about moving to Dallas so she could pursue her modelling dreams.
She never made it home.
Somewhere in that busy shopping mall, a man approached her. He was well-dressed, charming, and had a camera around his neck. He told her he was a fashion photographer. He told her she had the look. He told her he could make her dreams come true.
His name was Christopher Wilder. And he was one of the most dangerous men in America.
What Susie didn't know — what nobody in Oklahoma knew — was that the FBI was already hunting Wilder across multiple states. He was a race car driving millionaire with a beautiful home in Florida and a savage secret. He had already killed several young women. He posed as a photographer to lure his victims. And he was very, very good at it.
"She was naive about life," her brother John says quietly. "I think absolutely she would have gone with him, thinking he was genuine."Her brother David just nods. "She was super naive."
When Brian Logan finished his shift and Susie didn't come to pick him up, he went home thinking she'd forgotten. When she wasn't there either, he panicked and ran to the police.
They told him she'd probably had a fight and walked out. They did almost nothing. While the FBI was deploying massive resources to find Wilder in Florida, police in Oklahoma didn't even know he existed. They didn't search for Susie's car. Her husband and her mother found it themselves — still sitting in the Penn Square Mall car park, five days later, exactly where Wilder had left it. Her family hired a private detective in desperation. He cracked the case in seven hours. The police hadn't managed it in ten days.
By then it was already too late.
Wilder had driven Susie across the state line into Kansas, checked into a motel room under a false name, and requested the end room nearest the car park. He had an electric torture device plugged into the wall and had sprayed the bedsheets with his mother's favourite perfume.
What he put Susie through in that room is almost too terrible to write.
The next morning he drove her to Milford Lake. She was bleeding heavily from multiple stab wounds. He dragged her across rocky ground, left her under a cedar tree, and drove away. Susie Logan was still breathing when he left her there to die alone.
He then drove to a nearby town and ordered a steak lunch.
A passing fisherman found Susie's body that afternoon. She was identified from her description on a national database — ten days after she was reported missing. Her family learned she was dead when CNN broadcast her photograph on television.
She was still 21 years old.
Her brothers John and David — both former US Navy men who between them served over 50 years — agreed to speak publicly about Susie for the first time in forty years for the Catching Evil podcast. What makes their conversation almost unbearable to listen to is the revelation that in all that time, these two strong, private men had never truly spoken to each other about what happened to their little sister.
"For 40 years I couldn't talk about it," John says. "When I saw her at the funeral home, I just went into shutdown. That was my way of dealing with it."
David was just ten years old when Susie was murdered. At the funeral he asked his father to wait so he could hold his sister's hand one last time. It is a moment he has never forgotten.
"It wasn't her anymore," he says, his voice breaking. "She was such a sweet, sweet, tender little human being."
Their mother Agnes never recovered. A year after her daughter's murder she wrote a letter to a newspaper that remains one of the most devastating pieces of writing you will ever read — a mother's raw fury at the system that failed her beautiful girl, asking simply: Does anyone care?
Susie's sister-in-law Robyn, who had never once heard her husband John speak about Susie in all their years of marriage, listened to the brothers talk and said something that will stay with you long after the episode ends.
"I wish she was here with us right now," Robyn said. "I think she and I would have been the best of friends. I feel like she meant something to so many people. And to this day, as we sit here, she continues to make a difference."
Susie Logan wanted to be a model, a fashion designer, and most of all, a mother. She was robbed of every single one of those dreams by a man who should never have been free to walk among normal people.
Her brothers are finally telling her story. It is time the world listened
______________________________________
JOIN THE HUNT FOR THE TRUTH:
You can support our investigation by liking, subscribing and sharing Catching Evil on your favourite platform.
Your support will help us to reach more listeners, dig deeper into these cases, and continue uncovering the truth.
But we don’t just want you to listen—we want to hear from you. Do you have any information, personal stories, or insights related to the cases we cover? Did you cross paths with Christopher Wilder?
Email us here:
CLICK to record your message for us:
______________________________________
5 THINGS EPISODE 10 OF CATCHING EVIL WILL MAKE YOU THINK ABOUT LONG AFTER YOU'VE LISTENED
1. The police failure that cost Susie her life — and how little has changed
When Brian Logan reported his wife missing, Oklahoma City police told him she'd probably had a fight and walked out. They didn't search for her car. They didn't check the national missing persons database. They did almost nothing. Meanwhile the FBI was deploying enormous resources to find Christopher Wilder — in completely the wrong state. The two agencies weren't talking to each other, and Susie paid for that with her life. Her mother Agnes put it best in her devastating letter: a private detective found her daughter in seven hours. The police couldn't do it in ten days. Ask yourself — how much has really changed?
2. Predators don't look like monsters — they look like opportunity
Wilder didn't grab Susie off the street. He walked up to a young woman with modelling dreams in a busy shopping mall and told her exactly what she wanted to hear. He was well-dressed, charming, and had a camera around his neck. He offered her a future. Susie wasn't foolish or reckless — she was a normal young woman who responded the way most of us would have. We tell our daughters to be polite and trusting. Episode 10 asks a deeply uncomfortable question: is that actually keeping them safe?
3. Grief doesn't have an expiry date — and silence makes it worse
John and David Logan are big, strong men who between them gave over 50 years to the US Navy. Yet in this episode both of them break down. And the most extraordinary revelation is that in forty years they had never properly spoken to each other about what happened to their little sister. John describes losing his sense of humour overnight — he was the family comedian before Susie died and simply never got it back. David describes the guilt of feeling happy about anything. Their story is a powerful reminder that unprocessed grief doesn't disappear. It just goes underground and damages everything around it.
4. The women who almost became victims — and what saved them
Just hours after leaving Susie to die, Wilder walked into a bar in Junction City, Kansas and targeted Kelly — an 18-year-old playing in a pool competition with her baby beside her. He used the same photographer routine. He pushed hard. He even told her to bring the baby. Kelly said no. In this episode Kelly speaks about that encounter for the first time, and it is chilling — not just because of how close she came, but because of how normal it all seemed in the moment. Her story, alongside Susie's, forces us to think hard about how we teach young women to handle exactly these situations.
5. Telling the story matters — even forty years later
John's wife Robyn had never heard her husband speak about his sister in all their years of marriage. Not once. By the end of the evening she was in tears saying she believes Susie lives on in their children. David speaks to his sister still, asking her for guidance. And across America, women have been coming forward after hearing Catching Evil — out of the darkness, as one described it — to share their own stories and provide information that is now in the hands of law enforcement. Suzanne Logan was nearly one of the forgotten ones. Episode 10 makes sure she never will be again.
Would you like me to write social media posts to accompany these pieces, or headlines and subheadings optimised for different platforms?
_____________________________________________
David with his children, the niece and nephew Susie never got to meet.
_________________________________________________
Catching Evil is committed to making a meaningful impact in the lives of those affected by violent crime, particularly in light of the chilling legacy of serial killer Christopher Wilder, who left behind a still-growing number of victims. In our pledge to honour these individuals and support their families, we donate to not-for-profit groups in both America and Australia.
Survivors of Homicide Inc, based in Connecticut, provides help to anyone who has lost a loved one to violent crime.
All services are offered to members free of charge, including one-on-one counselling, support groups, court support throughout the judicial process and personal advocacy in working with law enforcement and other community agencies.
It was founded in 1983, just before Christopher Wilder went on his rampage, by a group of families trying to cope with the murder of a loved one that shattered their lives.
When you donate to Yesterday Today Tomorrow Women, you are investing in the empowerment of women across generations. This Florida-based not-for-profit was founded by Kris Conyers, who was abducted off the street at gunpoint by Christopher Wilder with her sister when she was 11 years old.
YTT Women is dedicated to advancing women’s mental health and social wellbeing. Contributions directly support community-based initiatives that raise awareness, provide resources, and foster safe, supportive spaces for women to grow and heal.
Mary’s House Services was founded in 2015 by a dedicated group of concerned citizens from Sydney’s northern suburbs, close to where Christopher Wilder was born and lived wth his family. Members of the local clergy, health authorities, philanthropists and community and business leaders came together to help provide safety for women and their children, victim-survivors of violence and abuse.
Mary’s House refuge was established to address the significant gap in government-funded services and to save lives by providing critical support and a safe space for people to cope with their trauma and begin to rebuild their lives.
How to donate: https://mhs-summer-appeal-2025.raiselysite.com/#donate
Comments